I said that CGC is saying they have a stance and it's that they don't believe it. I'm saying that they have a stance and it's that they do.
I got that, obviously. Except he is fully wrong - no theist belief system takes any view on it
either way, so by agreeing that they do you're helping his argument continue instead of stopping it dead in its tracks.
all you need are religious people from that particular religion to tell you.
that would be meaningless. Even if you polled every member, the results would be different every year. Because it has no relevance to their religion at all. Aliens have nothing to do with God, therefore the argument is pointless. How many times does this need to be said before you get it.